Re: Brock Nov. 9 Essay
Date sent: Tue, 13 Nov 2001 11:30:07
From: "Sean Oberle" <Analysis@keepandbeararms.com>
Copies to: <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Subject: Brock Nov. 9 Essay
To the Editor,
Karen Brock's November 9 essay,
Men, Handguns a Most Dangerous Mix for Women, is bald propaganda. I note with
a chuckle that she repeats the false distinction of her organization, Violence
Policy Center (VPC): that the firearm industry somehow fools women into fearing
attacks from strangers rather than from those they know. Leaving aside that
VPC never has provided evidence of this alleged misdirection, whether a woman
knows her attacker has nothing to do with whether the firearm is useful.
I am left wondering just what VPC
is suggesting by comparing women who purchase guns to men who kill women with
guns. Is VPC suggesting that the men use the women's own guns to kill the women?
The group provides zero evidence of this. Is VPC suggesting that if a man kills
a woman with HIS gun that makes HER gun, a different gun, dangerous to
her? That would be laughably illogical on its face.
In the end, Brock and VPC have erected
a strawman argument so that they can repeat a variation of a long-discredited
gun control factoid: comparing murders and suicides to self-defense killings,
which falsely suggests that the only method of defense with a firearm is to
kill. It excludes all acts of self-defense that involve injuries, warning shots
or simply showing the weapon.
Gun Control Analyst, KeepAndBearArms.com
To Get Your Letters Printed Here
Click here and read submission guidelines.